Collect 5 presents
Collect 10 presents
Collect 15 presents
Collect 20 presents
Collect 3 puzzle pieces
Collect 6 puzzle pieces
Collect 9 puzzle pieces
Collect 12 puzzle pieces
Solve the puzzle minigame
Unwrap all 20 presents
Find and interact with 14 different objects in Ponyville (Sparkling objects all count as one)
Plant 6 flower without having a critter eat a seed in the Critter Minigame
Hit all 20 correct notes in the Chime Minigame
Complete the Butterfly Minigame within 50 seconds
Complete StarSong's Dancing Minigame without making an incorrect move
Complete the Watering Minigame without bumping into any obstacles
Collect all notes without letting any note fall off screen in the Notes Minigame
Collect all 30 balloons without losing a hot air balloon
Complete the Crayon Minigame within 25 seconds