Complete your first match
Hit an opponent with a steel chair
Watch 5 AI vs. AI battles
Lose 10 matches
Complete the tutorial in Story Mode
Win a falls count anywhere match outside the ring
Win a match after triggering a Second Wind
Win a cage match inside the "Chain Link" cage
Win a cage match inside the "Big Blue" cage
Miss an attack from the top of the cage
Win a match as Tommy Dreamer
Win a match as Matt Cardona
Win a match as Stevie Richards in the SRF Arena
Win a match as Johnny Retro
Win a match as Jeff Cobb
Win a match as Nick Aldis
Win a match as Brian Myers
Win a match as Warhorse in Warhorse's Hell Arena
Win a match as Zack Sabre Jr. by submission
Win a match as Colt Cabana
Win a match as Nikita Koloff in the NWA 70 Arena
Win a match as Nick Aldis against Austin Idol in the NWA Power arena
Complete 10 Pounds of Gold
Defeat your opponent within 3 minutes inside a steel cage
Win a 6-man tag team match as the Blue World Order
Win a Tag Team match as Hawk & Animal
Win a Tag match as Cardona & Myers in the STOMP In Paradise Arena
Complete 10 Pounds of Gold with 5 different wrestlers
Win a 3-way match with Tommy Dreamer in the Ballroom
Win 20 matches
Win 50 matches
Win a 4-way elimination match
Land 3 finishing moves in one match
Kick out of an opponent's finishing move
Successfully defend a championship in Exhibition Mode
Complete chapter 3 of Story Mode
Win a match in every arena
Win a Retro Rumble
Earn all other achievements
Win a match as Chris Bey
Win a match as James Storm after taunting 6 times
Win a match as Mr. Hughes
Complete Story Mode as a face
Complete Story Mode as a tweener
Complete Story Mode as a heel
Use a hidden kendo stick
Win 13 matches in Warhorse's Hell Arena
In Versus Mode, defend a championship 10 times in a row
Win your 100th match