Collect a locked present

Send an identified bad present to another player

Use Heal Friend Present on another player 10 times in one game

Use The Boom Box 4 times in one game

Hi-Five another player 3 times in one game

Get hit by Cupid's arrow 5 times in one game

Play as both old Skool TJ and as Old Skool Earl in a single game (co-op)

Give a life to another player 3 times in one game

Go for a ride in the Evil Elevator twice in one game

Make other player snap out of being in love by slapping them

Make other player wake up by shouting at them

Uncover all the map tiles for 3 levels within one game

Complete a fixed world game

Complete a random world game

Complete a game with a friend (local or online)

Play as each of the playable characters

Beat the 5th level in Rhythm Matching

Hide in sunflowers 4 times in a game when being chased by an Earthling

Successfully open 10 broken presents

Have 10 broken presents blow up on you

Pop 8 or more Earthlings who are dancing at a boombox

Pop a mole who has stolen one or more of your presents

Eat every type of food in one game

Save yourself from burning up by jumping in water

Visit a backer character

Catch Santa 3 times in one game

Catch 5 elves in one game

Unlock all power hats

Complete hard mode

Beat normal or hard mode without dying

Beat normal or hard mode without popping a single Earthling

Open an unidentified Major Randomizer, Total Bummer, or Instant Demotion after level 20

Beat normal or hard world without opening a single present

Visit all backer characters